1. Some members were not receiving emails sent from XJbikes.com. For example: "Forgot your password?" function to reset your password would not send email to some members. I believe this has been resolved now. Please use "Contact Us" form (see page footer link) if you still have email issues. SnoSheriff

    Hello Guest. You have limited privileges and you can't "SEARCH" the forums. Please "Log In" or "Sign Up" for additional functionality. Click HERE to proceed.

Copper v. Platinum v. Iridium

Discussion in 'XJ Technical Chat' started by omalley576, May 4, 2012.

  1. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    I wanted to get a sound-off on plugs. I'm about to replace mine and I'm weighing the pros and cons of each. But nothing can compare to real-world experience. Particularly if someone has used different metals in the same bike and can directly compare and contrast.

    Copper: cheaper, best conduction, highest thermal conductivity, gaps are spec'd assuming copper, shortest life.

    Platinum: mid-price, least conductive, lowest thermal conductivity, much greater life than copper.

    Iridium: most expensive, mid-conduction, mid-thermal conductivity (but closer to Platinum than copper), greater life than platinum.

    As an electrical engineer, I might be over-thinking this, but, spark energy and exact timing is directly related to the gap between terminals and the gas makeup in that gap as well as the "source impedance" of the terminals supplying the spark.

    A larger gap means more voltage has to build up before an arc can occur. So a larger gap will result in a longer time or delay until the spark occurs (we're talking hundreds of microseconds here, maybe single-digit milliseconds). (Side note, for reference: at 2000rpm a plug fires every 30ms, at 8000rpm it fires every 7.5ms). A larger gap will also mean more energy in the spark.

    A more conductive (less resistive) metal will result in more of the energy transferring to the spark, and less being lost in the resistance of the conductor. But, seriously, this has GOT to be negligible. Copper is about 50 times as conductive as platinum, which are the two extremes in conductivity. So that would mean that Platinum loses 50x as much energy to resistive losses than copper. However, one must also think about the percentage of total energy that is going into the spark vs into resistive losses. I would wager that it loses much less than 1% of the total energy in the resistive losses. Thus making conductivity not worth discussing [other than to make this point, right? ;) ]

    I originally thought that electrical conductivity might affect the voltage at which an arc would occur, thus affecting its timing and energy level. However, my second-thought on this is based on the fact that arcing is dependent on only a few things: the conductivity and dielectric strength of the material being arced through, and the surface area of the terminals. (Smaller terminals will arc at lower voltages (earlier) than larger terminals.)

    So on that thought, I've heard that there are differences in surface area between the different plug types. This could affect arcing voltage and would have to be compensated for by changing the gap.

    Thermal conductivity plays a role in pre-ignition. A plug that conducts heat away more poorly is more likely to get hot enough to ignite the compressed gasses early. This, of course, could be combated with high-octane fuels, IF it's even a problem. The worst thermally-conductive material might still never get that hot.

    Let me sum up my theories.

    Despite people claiming that you should stick to copper because of its superior electrical conductivity, the improvement is likely (without an actual analysis) moot. So don't look at conductivity at all when comparing.

    Thermal conductivity could potentially play a role, and an analysis or simply a real-world experience could answer this question. Not to mention, if the worst thermally conductive material did cause pre-ignition, it could potentially be avoided with higher octane levels. This is where I want the most sounding-off.

    If there is indeed a difference in surface area of electrodes between the different plug materials, this would need to be compensated for by changing the gap to achieve the same voltage of arc. But I'm not sure the surface area claims I've heard are true.

    So if all other things being equal, longest life should prevail.

    /rant

    Anyone have problems with detonation (pre-ignition, knock, ping) using Platinum or Iridium that doesn't happen when you use copper?

    Anyone know if there are surface area differences between plug types?

    Any anecdotes on performance, sound, feel, or other noticeable differences when you used two or more different plug metals?

    Sorry for the long post. I'm verbose and thorough and often write through stream-of-consciousness.

    And now, some data (source:wikipedia):

    ||Metal|| ||Melting Point|| ||Electrical Conductivity|| ||Thermal Conductivity||
    ||Copper|| ||1085 C|| ||59.6 x 10^6 S/m|| ||401 W/(m K)||
    ||Platinum|| ||1768 C|| ||9.52 x 10^6 S/m|| ||72 W/(m K)||
    ||Iridium|| ||2466 C|| ||21.23 x 10^6 S/m|| ||147 W/(m K)||
     
  2. TIMEtoRIDE

    TIMEtoRIDE Active Member

    Messages:
    4,686
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Clermont FL near Orlando
    Copper ?? They use a copper CORE to help conduct heat, but it's inside IRON, or steel. It will rust, not turn green.

    Electricity jumps something like 27% easier from sharp edges, which new plugs have, and what the THIN Platinum electrode similates. And I don't think they run the "less conductive" Platinum thru the whole plug - - just the tip, it's too expensive.

    There's also an air-gap INSIDE spark plugs, which helps them fire.

    I file my plugs square, then gap to 0.027" , just inside spec, as XJ's have weak coils.

    An increased gap WILL retard timing, I don't know by how much.
     
  3. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Right. But these are the terms used to differentiate plugs and these metals are their primary makeup. And copper on the outside would just sputter away, anyway with all that arcing. I do realize it is not 100% copper/platinum/iridium. But these are the primary conduction paths and these are the materials that typically make up the bulk.

    And now that I think even more about it, the iron or steel in copper is a pretty poor conductor (relatively), but there is so little of it that the copper still dominates.

    The spark gap inside the plug helps with dV/dt at the terminal. Arcing is actually a function of MANY things. Gas composition, pressure, electrode shape, dV/dt (how fast the voltage rises). I used to build large spark gaps for R&D projects. I could almost write a dissertation. (If I haven't already here).

    Point is, these materials could affect spark energy and timing and I want to know if anyone has seen any real differences.

    If anyone using platinum or iridium gapped within spec' and had no appreciable degradation of performance from knocking, retarded timing, overheated plugs, etc, then I'm going to go with iridium, because, at that point, longevity is the only determining factor, and despite the cost difference being huge as a percentage, it is not huge in dollars.

    If anyone knows of some industry research (by independent labs, schools or an engine manufacturer not paid off by the plug industry) that looks into these differences, I would love to see it!!!
     
  4. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    Long story short: The local roadrace team uses iridium plugs and opens the gap up somewhat from standard. Modern bikes have plenty of ignition umph for this and they actually can see a very slight power increase in some cases.

    Another long story short: We're running Denso Iridiums in both of our Turbo Secas and they actually made a difference, believe it or not.
     
  5. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Does an 82 XJ650J Maxim count as a "modern bike with the umph?" :)

    I was planning on buying an entire backup set, gapping to minimum, riding, gapping to nominal, riding, gapping to maximum, riding, and seeing if I could even tell a difference. If not, I'd keep those plugs in. If they were so bad they weren't drivable, just swap 'em out.
     
  6. Super

    Super Member

    Messages:
    75
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    A couple years ago I replaced the "regular" copper plugs with Iridium plugs in my 97 XJR, hoping to see some performance improvements however the car developed a rough, lumpy idle. I put copper plugs back in, problem solved.

    My Subaru H6 gets Iridium plugs, they are a challenge to change and the iridium plugs do last longer, which probably contributed to their development. Seems like manufacturers are striving for "maintenace free" for the life of a lease period.

    I run regular plugs in everything old as I'm not sold on any performance improvements using iridium.



    Dave
     
  7. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
    I just modified my timing plate to advance the timing 3 deg, what kind of plug/gap would it take to equal something like that. I think gap vs timing are insignificant.
    A more efficient coil might be a better place to look for improvements
     
  8. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    I wouldn't know where to begin on changing gap to effect timing changes. I only know that it will affect the timing. I also want to keep this on topic. Let's discuss the advantages/disadvantages of the various metals for spark plugs.

    Also, a "more efficient" coil is a loose definition. Efficient in what manner? And more efficient doesn't necessarily mean performance gains. If you change the coil you will change inductance, capacitance, resistance and this over all output impedance. This could result in more or less total energy being transferred to the spark. It could also change the time at which the energy transfer occurs (changing your timing) as well as the duration of the energy "pulse" (thus changing the power of the spark).

    Changing a component like that, however, is likely to have minimal effect because there are so many more dominant factors in play. In fact, this is one of the reasons they put air gaps inside spark plugs. Otherwise, just changing wires would have a huge impact.

    Think of it like your carbs. You change a seemingly tiny setting a top-performing bike becomes a non-starter. That's really sensitive to change. Depending on what coil you put in the mix, you could unbalance things in a way where they don't work, even if the coil is "better, faster, more powerful and more efficient."

    But, yeah, let's get back on topic.

    Advantages/disadvantages of various plug metals? the kind of reply Super posted is exactly what I'm looking for. I'm leaning towards copper because that was what the engine was designed for and what they used to spec the gap setting. Copper is also cheapest and better with heat. I don't mind changing them out too often. (Then again, I haven't done it yet, could be difficult on this bike...)
     
  9. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    Everything new and old that we put iridiums in has run fine (sparkplug-wise anyway :) ). And I'm talking about bikes from the 60s through present day. They just seem to make the most out of whatever energy is available.

    Barely Legal Bikes
    Athens, AL
    256-232-2160
     
  10. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    A fellow Alabamian. I've transplanted to Ohio two years ago. Miss my home. These folks don't know food, and they keep bragging about this stuff they call "chili" from Cincinnati.


    Anyway, fan or not I don't get enough of this anymore, so War Eagle.

    And thanks for your input. No loss in performance, any gains?
     
  11. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
  12. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
    If you have a High Performance Racing Engine which can be reconfigured by reprogramming the Fuel Injection, Timing, and Varying the Mixtures for Barometric Pressures and Relative Humidity just moments before the announcement to Start your engines, ... you might have reason to Index the Plugs.

    If you have BURIED Plugs, ... requiring the removal Body Panels, Intake Plenum, Coil Modules and Disconnecting Motor Mounts too Rotate the Engine Block to access the Plugs: Long Lasting Iridium Plugs are in order.

    But we have Engines which allow for the Plugs to be removed and discarded then replaced with New Plugs without fuss. Performance wise, we got nothing.

    Making a choice of what Plug you use is wholly dependent upon what the Advertising Agency has led you to believe makes their clients Spark Plug better than Brand-X in the space behind your eyes between your ears.

    It all depends on factors like:
    Your favorite color.
    Lighting Bolts.
    Mushroom Clouds
    Wild Horses stampeding.
    A Formation of Jet Aircraft

    And, ... Last ---> But not LEAST!

    Just how much you are willing to spend to see the bearded lady.
     
  13. TIMEtoRIDE

    TIMEtoRIDE Active Member

    Messages:
    4,686
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Clermont FL near Orlando
    I disagree, I have a tray full of Platinum plugs that would be worth Twenty Grand, easy, if Platinum were the MAIN Component.

    It's a short, 1/4 inch wire at the very tip, fused to a conductor in the insulation.

    No - it's not an alloy, it's a copper CORE inside a STEEL electrode. It may be true that the electricity finds the copper path easier, after crossing the air-gap, but the firing + terminal is steel.

    In fact - I don't know how they do it - embedding the copper into steel, blending special ceramics that transmit heat without cracking, rolling the threads, electro-plating the housing to prevent rust, welding the side electrode, stamping or imprinting the logo and info - - then selling it for $0.99 !! A spark plug is worth about $35.00 !!

    I sincerely hope you will stick around so we can learn alot from you.
    And I have no formal electrical training.
     
  14. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
  15. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
    somebody tell me about this "spark gap" inside a plug
     
  16. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
    "Our Spark Plugs are better than theirs."
    "Revolutionary New Power Multiplication Technology"
    "Sure they cost much more. But, we include a free sticker."
    "Our sticker is bigger than their sticker. We give you two."

    "Our Plugs are Guaranteed to make you go further, faster, save gas, make you popular with chicks and last a lifetime because they never wear-out and come with a sticker for every one you buy."**

    **Not Valid in:
    Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas
    California Colorado Connecticut Delaware
    Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho
    Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas
    Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland
    Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi
    Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada
    New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York
    North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma
    Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina
    South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah
    Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia
    Wisconsin Wyoming.
     
  17. fintip

    fintip Member

    Messages:
    817
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    Austin
    This is a freaking cool thread. I was just gapping spark plugs for the first time for a friend's XJ, and wondering how it could possibly matter--such a small difference, surely the bike wouldn't notice!

    Timing. Of course. Crazy. So running rich should increase impedance on the arcing tips, which should cause a need for more voltage to arc, which should also kind of screw with your timing a bit, no?

    ttride: yeah, there's lots of stuff like that. For instance, buying a machine that took Ph.D's to engineer, metals dug up from the earth from all over the world, purified, treated, measured down to hundreds and thousandths of an inch, assembled by further machinery specially designed to do so, etc., etc., all for only a couple hundred bucks--after international shipping?

    These bikes are pretty ridiculous. It's a fun game to think about what things you can get for less than $5 that required an assembly process involving precise manufacture and parts from around the globe. Weird economics, this world...
     
  18. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Rick, agreed. I like mushroom clouds and plane formations, they make me feel cooler and make my bike a sex object.

    I bought the regular ol' NGK BP7ES. Plain. Simple. Specified. (That is what was specified, right?)

    TIME, I didn't write that well. I meant "the iron or steel inside the copper-type plugs is a poor conductor, relative to copper." I didn't mean to suggest that the iron or steel were physically inside the copper, either as an alloy, or just meaning the copper was coating them.

    And by "making up the bulk" I misspoke a bit, too. I mean making up the bulk of the conducting path. However, I suppose with platinum and iridium they are just coatings on the outside of probably a copper core, just like "copper" plugs. The platinum or iridium are used since they have higher melting points resulting in less sputtering and longer life. This also allows manufacturers to make the tips smaller, thus focusing the electric field for more control over the spark. But again, this will affect timing and energy in the spark. Finally, they also make the tips smaller so that they will absorb less heat in the first place. Although, that seems silly to me, because they will eventually absorb heat once things warm up, but now the tip being small is also what causes it to lose heat more slowly.

    Yeah, I'm utterly amazed at the many things we manufacture in the world and the price we sell them at. I think my plugs were $8+ after tax for four. And if you look at a cross-section of plug design... woah.

    Polock, I've not found a design or patent file showing it, but I've heard before about the air gap inside a spark plug. But since I can't find something I'm skeptical of its existence. But the theory behind using one is common in a lot of pulsed power work where we use spark gaps. I'm talking BIG spark gaps and trying to reach multiple megavolts. Loud, sometimes destructive (and obviously cool) stuff!

    The idea is, you put two spark gaps in series. The 2nd gap to see the voltage across its terminals is typically setup such that it would normally fire at a much higher voltage than the 1st gap. However, spark gaps can be very sensitive to dV/dt (the rate of change of voltage over a specified time, or sometimes erroneously called just "rise time"). So you charge up gap 1 to the lower voltage, and you can do so slowly from a low-power supply. Spark gap 1 breaks down and conducts, thus increasing the voltage at the second gap VERY rapidly, and now the second gap will fire at a voltage much lower than typical, just because it happened so fast. Seen it, built it, done it. I've read the physics behind it once and it has to do with electron-hole migration and dipole moments of the gas inside the gap. Physics is truly an under-loved science. If we want our kids to learn and do amazing things to advance science, we simply need to get rid of all these safety rules and get them back into blowing crap up in school!!!

    Anyway, point is, that first gap helps regulate the second one. By controlling the geometry of the second gap and the connection to it (and the dielectric around it and a few other things) you can "regulate" much better how and when that second gap fires. So, it would make sense to employ something like this in spark plugs because minor variations in coil windings and their iron or ferrite cores that could change arcing voltage a few hundred volts are now factored out and dominated by other effects.

    fintip, I hadn't thought of that, but theoretically, yes, fuel/air mixture changes the gas composition which would change the arcing voltage and thus the exact time at which the arc occurs.

    The thing to keep in mind is what effects dominate and what effects are miniscule. Which ones do and don't are beyond me!!!
     
  19. bigfitz52

    bigfitz52 Well-Known Member Premium Member

    Messages:
    21,283
    Likes Received:
    418
    Trophy Points:
    83
    Location:
    Rural SE Michigan 60 miles N of Motown
    The air-gap thing is an old shade-tree mechanic's trick to get an oily or fouled plug to fire:

    Simply cut the plug wire about 2" away from the plug, and tape it to a popsicle stick with about 3/8" gap between the two cut ends.

    CBE (crude but effective) it does work.
     
  20. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
    Top 10 Most Popular Plugs

    1) NGK (4218) CR8EIX Iridium IX
    $10.50 ea.
    2) AUTOLITE 3095 Small Engine
    $.45 ea.
    3) NGK (2477) ZFR5FIX-11 Iridium IX
    $9.89 ea.
    4) BOSCH (4501) FGR8DQI Platinum IR Fusion
    $9.45 ea.
    5) NGK (7131) BPR6ES Traditional
    $4.50 ea.
    6) NGK (7803) DPR7EIX-9 Iridium IX
    $10.50 ea.
    7) NGK (5464) BKR5EIX-11 Iridium IX
    $10.50 ea.
    8. NGK (6418) BKR6EIX Iridium IX
    $10.29 ea.
    9) NGK (3199) BKR6EQUP Multi-Ground
    $10.60 ea.
    10) NGK (3764) BKR6EIX-11 Iridium IX
    $10.50 ea.

    . . . . . . . . . .
     
  21. darkfibre

    darkfibre Member

    Messages:
    671
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    XJs dont run high energy ignition systems, and the main reason for us to replace plugs is due to fouling NOT electrode wear. Having a spark plug that will last 100,000 klms of wear is not useful if it is getting contaminated.
    We are creating a spark under pressure between 2 electrodes using a finite electrical potential. There are no huge advantages in that spark energy to be had by changing the type of metal on the electrodes.
     
  22. darkfibre

    darkfibre Member

    Messages:
    671
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    Not enough to be measured with a timing light, until you get to the point of a continuous missfire.

    I have done this to solve an argument. Try it.
     
  23. bigfitz52

    bigfitz52 Well-Known Member Premium Member

    Messages:
    21,283
    Likes Received:
    418
    Trophy Points:
    83
    Location:
    Rural SE Michigan 60 miles N of Motown
    I dunno. NONE of my used XJ plugs are fouled or contaminated; I replace them because the ground strap erodes to where it has a soft, rounded section compared to the nice sharp rectangular cross section of a new plug's ground strap. The tip of the electrode likewise becomes gently rounded; once deteriorated, I replace the plugs.

    For me, that's every 2500~3000 miles or so in a properly tuned stock 550 that sees a lot of high-speed miles, running stock NGK D8EA plugs.

    Cost is less than a tank of gas, so I simply consider it part of keeping the motor running at its best.
     
  24. MercuryMan

    MercuryMan Active Member

    Messages:
    1,154
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Springdale, NWA
    Currently running stock NGK's. I haven't tried them, but E3's have been independently tested to increase the flame front and dispersion of flame-which leads to more complete and more powerful combustion. How much? Well that's the question to have answered, and I wouldn't go by manufacturer's tests-only a real world test would convince me. But if they improved power/fuel economy even a little I would buy them.
     
  25. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
    Fitz, don't cut the wire, just pull the boot up off the plug a little.
    last time i changed plugs, about two years ago, i bought eight and swapped them around to index them. got three right on and one close.
    did it do any good? i doubt it but i've got indexed plugs and i sleep better at night :)
     
  26. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
    The invention of the first commercially viable high-voltage spark plug, as part of a magneto-based ignition system, by Robert Bosch's engineer Gottlob Honold in 1902 made possible the development of the internal combustion engine.
    Subsequent manufacturing improvements can also be credited to Albert Champion and others.

    It the device that makes Internal Combustion Plants ... possible.

    From 1902 to 2012 the Automotive Industry's growth went Global.
    Manufacturers who can attract even a small niche' ... a small fraction of a percent ... of the Global Automotive Parts Market ... make vast fortunes if they can get consumers to buy their parts.

    The Basic Spark Plug has remained the same for all those years.
    Protected by Patents.
    Some Patents expired allowing for competitors to sell a different Brand.

    To be able to enter the market and not violate Patent rights; "Different Designs" were introduced along with claims of superiority.

    The MISSION of the Companies which have emerged with variations of Electrodes and Ground Straps with claims of providing a better Spark than the designs of Pioneers and their improved manufacturing processes is NOT about performance.

    It's about SALES.
     
  27. TIMEtoRIDE

    TIMEtoRIDE Active Member

    Messages:
    4,686
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Clermont FL near Orlando
    I read it somewhere a long time ago, so I went looking for it - Google Images, tune-up articles, old VW info, then I just took a hammer and smashed a Bosch Platinum plug open. No air gap.

    Odd that the center electrode does NOT conduct electricity, according to my Digital Multi-Meter.

    I'm not wrong, just mis-informed :oops:
     
  28. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
  29. darkfibre

    darkfibre Member

    Messages:
    671
    Likes Received:
    4
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Perth, Australia
    I replaced my plugs recently at 11,000 klms when I was about to do a dyno run (before removing the old engine). They were oil fouled due to the condition of the old engine. It will be interesting to see what mileage I will get out of the plugs with the new engine. Possibly shorter because of the engine mods, which I expect will require colder plugs.
     
  30. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Wait... whaaaaat? Something is amiss there. Either I'm misunderstanding what you are saying or had a piece of ceramic posing as a spark plug.

    That lack of continuity would suggest there's an air gap, though.

    Lastly, NEVER trust a multimeter to tell you if something conducts or not. They will only tell you if something is a dead short ... to DC. And those pulsed currents are anything but DC. So even if you measured the resistance with a DMM, you are only measuring the DC resistance. It's a whole different world when you have time-varying voltage and current.
     
  31. TIMEtoRIDE

    TIMEtoRIDE Active Member

    Messages:
    4,686
    Likes Received:
    11
    Trophy Points:
    38
    Location:
    Clermont FL near Orlando
    My new NGK BP7ES and some old AC plugs conduct,
    but SOME of my Bosch Platinums (used) don't conduct, even after sanding the terminals.

    [​IMG]
     
  32. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    That's interesting. Again, though, you've got your DMM on diode-check. i would suggest setting it to ohms and checking the actual resistance. And even that won't give you a clear answer. But if your plugs normally conduct and a few don't... well then something is clearly different with those that don't. Perhaps it's inside the threaded bit?
     
  33. greg_in_london

    greg_in_london Member

    Messages:
    197
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    London
    I had this discussion with a friend who was on a professional motorcycle mechanic course at Merton College. They had had a visit from a NGK spark plug salesman (I think, at the time Champion were advertising 100% copper plugs) and were told that they had a solid copper core all the way through.

    I told him this was nonsense. I had an idea that there electrode was in two parts and joined with a paste, which could be damaged by petrol penetration if the engine was run with that cylinder not firing. I never had any evidence apart from my own thought to back that up, but spark plugs run in non-firing cylinders do seem to die.

    Whether I was right or not, I put an old plug in the vice and liberally applied tender care to separate it into its component parts and showed him where the two parts of the electrode were joined. It did look like there was a paste joining them, but it's just as possible other manufacturers could have a small air gap, or maybe just a conductive paste which is less than 100% effective, and still transmit a spark.

    Compared to bikes I had in the past, I think of XJs as high energy systems. I had Czech two-strokes, Jap bikes with magnetos and still have a Sanglas 500. The 10-20,000 volts of 80s Jap bikes should be enough for what we need. I don't doubt that you can get higher powered systems now, but then you have to get into all the theories about HT leads as well to get full benefit from it I suppose.
     
  34. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Power isn't just in the voltage, it's the current behind that. P=I*V, and so many things in that spark plug, the wires, the mixture, the ignition coil (or the digital ignition system) will all affect that.

    The "paste" may be a dielectric gel. This would make whatever gap the paste was filling become a capacitor (which is exactly what a spark gap really is). And this would allow the charge to reach a certain point, then arc through. It would seem odd to do it that way, though, because any dielectric I've ever heard of would create a carbon trail after one firing and then begin to conduct instead of hold off charge.

    If I have time after fighting with a broken intake bolt and a broken filter housing bolt I might just feel inclined to dissect an old plug. I mean, at least that's one thing I could break that would be somewhat productive!!!!!!
     
  35. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    If I had a dollar for every low-time conventional NGK (not the Platinum and/or Iridium NGKs) that would fire outside the cylinder, but NOT inside under compression, I'd have a lot of dollars. Cleaning makes no difference, and they almost never show ANY noticeable electrode erosion. We have seen this for years now, but don't see it with the other brands of conventional plugs we use (typically equivalent Autolites these days). We've even had customers come in without the bike/atv, etc. involved and ask us about this same NGK problem that has occurred REPEATEDLY to THEM. We tell them what to use, and they tell us later "Problem solved, thank you". :)
     
  36. greg_in_london

    greg_in_london Member

    Messages:
    197
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    London
    Yep - they wear out, but what causes it and what is it that failed ?

    A flooded, non firing cylinder at 200psi - could it force petrol up the side of the electrode ? What would the effect be ?

    Are NGKs the only plugs to have a two part electrode (presumably not) and are they still made the same way ?

    Why does a brown cow give white milk when it only eats green grass ?
     
  37. Polock

    Polock Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    9,751
    Likes Received:
    2,097
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Location:
    Beaver Falls, PA
    what would the # of a plug with a air gap be? mfg's break the plug # down to what each part means, anyone ever see "air gap = .15".
    how about "new improved air gap", "super air gap", "surefire air gap"
    "air gap between my ears". why would it be a secret? we got a air gap and they don't, don't tell anybody.
    they used to call bosch plugs with a center electrode and four side electrodes that you didn't set the gap on "air gap plugs" maybe that's how this got started.
    or maybe their marine plugs that float if you drop them in the lake?
     
  38. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    greg_in_london: Very good questions that I don't know the answer to (yet). Being an old Mechanical/Aerospace Engineer I would love to find the time to find out what's going on. I DO know that NGKs of 20-30 years ago didn't do this crap. They were FINE spark plugs.

    P.S. I'm not even referring to fuel-SOAKED plugs here, in fact most of them wouldn't even be accurately described as fouled. But, even if a new plug IS fuel-soaked, there's no excuse for this kind of permanent loss of function.
     
  39. RickCoMatic

    RickCoMatic Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    13,843
    Likes Received:
    65
    Trophy Points:
    48
    Location:
    Massachusetts, Billerica
  40. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    I see the suspicious-looking (soft?) stuff in the cross-section, but what is it??
     
  41. greg_in_london

    greg_in_london Member

    Messages:
    197
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    London
    The resistor plug shows a large area of ceramic conductor/resistor (5K Ohms) on their web page. I'll see if I can find a picture of the non-resistor plug to see if it shows how the two parts join.
    [​IMG]

    This one has suppression, rather than being a resistor plug. It has a paste joining the two parts of the electrode:
    [​IMG]

    And this site seems to have the best technical information, but looking at the cross section of the standard plug, it looks as if it might have been simplified as there are steps in the insulation which refelct nothing in the electrode.

    http://www.ngkspark.co.nz/sparkplug_tech.php#

    [EDIT - more info]
    I found an online patent which explains more about the construction of a plug at
    Patents Online
    which refers to :
    "The resistor is made of a glass mixed with a conductive material (such as carbon black, metal and the like), where blending (proportion) of the metal is not considerably high. Thus, joining the resistor directly to the metals {that is, the center electrode and the terminal metal fitting} is very often of difficulty. Therefore, a conductive glass seal layer which is made of a mixture of metal (in plenty) and glass is conventionally interposed between the resistor and the center electrode, and between the resistor and the terminal metal fitting, for improving joint strength."

    This picture shows a solid copper plug with the join much higher in the plug.[​IMG]

    I'm not sure if this has added much to the discussion, but at least we have more pictures...
     
  42. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    "The resistor is made of a glass mixed with a conductive material (such as carbon black, metal and the like), where blending (proportion) of the metal is not considerably high."

    Hmmmm...sounds similar to the way the old style non-metallic core spark plug wires were made. And they wore out (conductively) over time. And, of course, the resistors in spark plug caps wear out as well.
     
  43. R211007314

    R211007314 New Member

    Messages:
    7
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    1
    Location:
    Medina, Ohio
    I put iridium in my 1986 Maxim X... It starts first time no choke... I can feel more power maybe since they are new plugs? ... I am not an electrician but I had great results...



    Denso IX24 NGK DR8EIX: http://www.maxim-x.com/sparkplugs.html
     
  44. Rhettb3

    Rhettb3 Member

    Messages:
    156
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    South of the cities, MN

    Do you possibly know which ones you put in? I was going to get some but the guy at the auto parts store didn't know which ones I'd need... I'm curious to see if they make any difference...
     
  45. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Seriously? Were you able to start without choke before this plug change? Did you change anything else at the same time you changed your plugs. Not to sound like a naysayer, but it seems to me to go completely against many laws of physics for a simple spark plug change to affect your cold starting ability and give you any noticeable power gains. The only thing a better plug could do is improve the timing and burn rate of your fuel, which could net you maybe a horsepower or two, but would more likely improve fuel economy in a more noticeable way than HP.

    That is, unless you had some plugs that weren't firing properly before the change. In which case, you didn't see a performance "gain," you just got things back to where they should have been, anyway.


    Not sure about your bike, but I thought all of these used the NGK BP7ES. Whatever your bike uses, Advance, O'Reilly, Autozone, any of those places should be able to cross-reference your stock part number to other manufacturers and style of plugs that meet the same spec. Just make sure you gap correctly!
     
  46. Rhettb3

    Rhettb3 Member

    Messages:
    156
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    South of the cities, MN
    Mine uses Dr8es-L, i asked the guy at orielys and he said the computer didn't show any iridium replacements, he was probably being lazy and didn't want to cross reference...
     
  47. omalley576

    omalley576 Member

    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    6
    Location:
    Columbus, Ohio
    Yeah... they do that. When I find a guy like that I make it a point to tell him I'm waiting for someone else to help me. I don't even fuss with them. They aren't worth the time or the extra air-breathing required. That's just pathetic. Probably ignorant to the ability to do that and too lazy to care.
     
  48. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    The Denso Iridium IX24 will fix you right up.
     
  49. Rhettb3

    Rhettb3 Member

    Messages:
    156
    Likes Received:
    0
    Trophy Points:
    16
    Location:
    South of the cities, MN
    Thanks for the info!
     
  50. oilheadron

    oilheadron Member

    Messages:
    121
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    18
    Location:
    Athens, AL
    Glad to help. BTW, don't try to gap them. The center electrodes are fragile and DON'T need to be regapped to the original specs anyway.
     

Share This Page